If the Titan submersible disaster taught us anything, it’s that carbon isn’t the right material for every job. Also, narcissistic autocracy isn’t a great CEO model. Still, even the Titan’s pressure hull was capable of withstanding 3000 psi of pressure, roughly half of that at which it imploded. Incidentally, that’s also the filling pressure of…
Carbon Canisters and Graceful Safety Design
Carbon please.

Left to right: Mammut carbon, ARVA carbon, Mammut Aluminum
Responses
-
Interesting article. As a BCA Float user, I wonder if it is possible to use a carbon canister in place of the original one. I’m headed to Europe soon and could pick one up easily.
-
Unfortunately, BCA does not have a carbon canister available. Though some brands appear to have a similar head on their canisters, they differ in important, invisible specs, such as the force required to puncture the disc in the head. For that reason, it is highly unadvisable to mix brands.
-
-
So I have a mammut aluminum air cylinder on one of my bags now. Given the Arva is the same head and air, couldn’t I use that instead of the mammut aluminum to save space and weight?
-
The correct answer is no. The puncture disc that needs to be broken to release the air is different in the two. You could risk an incomplete puncture or failure of the pucnturing needle to retract, which could give a weak inflation pressure or failure to deploy. Given that you have a Mammut bag, your best option is to find someone to buy a Mammut carbon cylinder for you in Europe and either send it to you or bring it back for you. You can always keep the aluminum cylinder as a backup or to use for travel as needed.
-





Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.