UIAA Recommendations to Reduce EMI in Avalanche Transceivers

EMI, it's a thing. Items found in the closet/pack that could interfere with an avalanche transceiver. Note: pictured here are heated gloves–these are not recommended for backcountry skiing! Missing from the pile—a cell phone (used to take the photo). The point is, we are carrying lots of devices that cause active EMI.

  On Dec. 6, the International Climbing and Mountaineering Federation (UIAA) released their recommendations for the use of avalanche transceivers in proximity to other devices we carry (or that might be in the environment, like overhead power lines) that emit electromagnetic radiation. Electromagnetic radiation can cause electromagnetic interference, known as EMI. EMI is a big…

Responses

  1. Slim

    I had not thought about this before, but just thought of this if you use radios:
    Having a radio clipped to the outside, like Rocky Talkies , or a power switch on the mic, like the BCA Link 2.0, is really an essential feature.
    Our current radios are inexpensive, and have worked well. But , they sit inside my pack, with a mic clipped to the shoulder. I’d hate to have to dig in my pack after an avalanche to turn the radio off.

    1. Jason Albert

      Slim, had a similar thought as I thread the Rocky Talkie handheld mic from the pack’s innards to secure it on the shoulder strap…no on/off switch on the handheld mic. That means a step or two to access the radio unit (zipped into an electronics pocket inside the pack’s main compartment) to turn the unit off. That’s something I’ll consider moving forward—do I want the handheld mic if it in fact takes me longer to power down the unit in the even of a victim search?

    2. bruised

      Watch Bruce Edgerly’s talk at 52 min in he puts up a chart of the interference potential causes and distances – FRS radios (bca link, original rocky talky) are not a significant source of interference and don’t generally need to be turned off, he sorta discusses some newer VHF’s as a bigger issue (this may end up including the new rocky talky 5w). I find FRS’s indispensable and I personally would never tell anyone to turn one off in an avalanche, nor have had any issues with them when doing drills. If you are worried I feel like the go to take away from edgerly’s talk is – arms length generally gets you away from basically everything that is not a snowmobile.

      1. Jason Albert

        Certainly lots to consider, and it is interesting to watch Bruce’s talk (which is excellent) in the context of the UIAA recommendations. I’ve always used a 2W radio (no handheld mic). Certainly it will be a power uptick with a 5W radio. The video does get into the VHF radios and mentions the issues some ski patrollers have noticed—it sounds like those are 5W radios they are using, but the model/make is not defined. And the arm’s length go-to has always been, generally speaking, my rule too. That noted, it was eye opening to see the >10m distance from a turned on phone, radio, or satellite communication device recommended by the UIAA. That’s a big difference between arm length (50cm) and 10m. And still, yeah, the UIAA states to “Switch off communication and other electronic devices (completely OFF, no airplane mode).” Best for me to go practice in the field with the 5W radio and transceiver in search mode.

        1. Ben Coffman

          San Juan Snowcast had a good episode recently that shared some interesting test results from a course with Edgerly that perhaps introduce some additional nuance. Ex: passive interference from a phone (can’t recall if the phone was powered on but inactive or powered off) only interfered with a beacon in send mode when the phone was literally against the beacon battery in the same pocket. Seems like maybe there is a little bit of room to make your own informed decisions about beacons and interference in send mode (ex. maybe it’s fine to just keep your phone in one pants pocket and your beacon in the opposite pocket). But it definitely seems wildly irresponsible to not maintain at least 50 cm in search when you’re being counted on for a rescue. (At least until fine search, when it appears that leaning over and accidentally lowering the distance from interference isn’t so a big deal because of how strong the beacon signals are at that point). I’d be pretty interested in the raw data that the 10m from phone/radio rec is coming from. Unless it’s truly necessary to go rooting through your pack powering down devices that time seems better used starting the search.

        2. Steve Bohrer

          I’m sure the UIAA and manufacturers have done much more comprehensive research than I have, but here’s my personal experience. Using my own beacon (Barryvox S) and devices I normally have with me, I did a series of backyard experiments. Based on what I saw, the iPhone was by far the biggest problem, maybe the only problem piece of electronic equipment. In search mode, with the phone in my front pocket, I saw ghost signals, random changes in distance and direction, and less range to initially pick up the transmitting signal. It was really bad if I moved the phone closer. Interestingly, just moving the phone to my back pocket seemed to completely eliminate the interference. I didn’t see any perceptible effects with a GoPro, inReach (not transmitting) 2W BCA radio (standby or transmitting) or even a 5W Baofeng with the transmitter held down and holding it essentially right next to the beacon.

          So based on my admittedly limited and personal experience, I really doubt any radio base unit in a backpack with a remote shoulder mic would have any effect on a beacon search. But I would absolutely not argue with the UIAA or manufacturer recommendations. I think we should all periodically incorporate some interferences into our ongoing training scenarios so everyone could recognize what EMI looks like on their beacons and not waste a lot of time chasing ghosts.

  2. Beacon.shovel.bearspray

    I may have just missed this, but are certain CLASSES of airbag packs “worse” than others? I’m picturing supercapacitor fan-style packs to have more electronic gadgetry and EMI than a canister system, but do realize that is total conjecture on my part and may be wildly wrong?

    1. Slim

      If it’s a fully mechanical system like most canister systems, it won’t have any effect, other than the small pieces of metal. Since they are not covering your beacon, it shouldn’t be an issue.

      Electronic ones have varying levels of interference.

      I came here to remind people to check if there is a software update for their airbag.
      I had not checked that for our E1 packs. I just did it, even though it’s been out for a long time.
      They changed the LED flash pattern, to a longer pause. This seriously reduces effects of false signals on searching beacons, according to a magazine article I read and their own info. That article also mentioned BD updated their software to reduce interference.

  3. Patrick Fink

    Our experience at Snowbird doing beacon drills while using commercial Motorola radios was that there was significant interference between radio and beacon. The radio would cause ghosting of 2+ burials and make direction guidance jump all over the place. About 1m of distance was required between radio and beacon, which meant that a patroller doing a hasty search had to shut off their radio. This was present with normal VHF radios and got MUCH worse when switching to a modern trunked/encrypted radio system, which is increasingly the system used by resorts. I think it’s reasonable to think that a radio with a higher transmitting power is more likely to interfere. Anyone with a programmable Baofeng radio could do a quick backyard experiment on this one.

    Also published in Wilderness and Environmental Medicine within the last year was a study showing interference from heating clothing, particularly gloves. I do t recall if there were heated boot liners included but those would be a concern as well.

  4. Slim

    I was out doing beacon drills with our new Barry S2s.
    We tested a set up with the ‘victim’ in a huddled position, legs close to chest. Beacon on chest, phone in airplane mode in leg pocket, so about 10-15cm apart.
    Searcher also had phone in leg pocket, beacon held up high. Inreach in top of backpack.
    I didn’t acquire the signal until I was less than 10 meters away in a straight line, and the distance reading was 14m. Besides the EMI sources on ourselves, there could also have been sources from the houses we were behind , about 35 meters away.
    So, I am not sure what the source of the EMI was. For comparison, most of the times when we buried a beacon in the same area, we were picking the first one up around 50m distance reading.

Leave a Reply